|
Wednesday, 9 November 2005
'GUNNS20' TO PROCEED WITH STRIKE-OUT APPLICATION
|
Legal teams for defendants in the matter of Gunns & Ors v Marr & Ors (the 'Gunns 20') have notified the Victorian Supreme Court of their intention to proceed with strike-out applications on the third version of the statement of claim.
This follows the successful strike-out of both the first and second versions in their entirety earlier this year.
Julian Burnside Q.C. (defense counsel) has commented that the third claim is, "
like a Rubik's cube that's been twisted around a few times; all the same bits are there, they're just in a different place."
Version Three claims nearly half a million dollars more in damages, taking the total claim from about $6.4 million to nearly $6.9 million.
Today is the deadline for legal teams for the defence to provide notice of their intention to proceed with a strike-out application on version three.
The decision to proceed with strike-out applications follows the provision of over 700 pages of further and better particulars on the statement of claim received from EMA Legal (lawyers for the plaintiffs).
Defendants will now await a date to be set by the court at which their strike-out applications on version three will be heard.
For further media comment:
Adam Burling 0429 966 171
(7th defendant)
Virginia Young 0417 223 280
(spokesperson for the 6th defendant, The Wilderness Society)
|
|
Tuesday 27th September 2005
ERODING DISSENT
|
ACT Greens MLA Deb Foskey will be speaking at an important
public forum tomorrow night on the threat of corporations using the law to
close down open society.
The forum is entitled "FORESTS AND FREE SPEECH the Gunns 20 story & how to
respond to strategic litigation against public participation." It will be
at 7:00 pm (Sept 28) at the Academy of Science Shine Dome, Gordon St, West
Civic.
The forum is part of a national awareness raising tour in response to the
ongoing legal action being taken by wood chip exporters Gunns Ltd against
environmental activists opposed to Gunns Forestry practices in Tasmania.
"This is an issue for everyone with an interest in civil society. Effective
democracy has to allow public action and debate to influence the decisions
of business and government, but many businesses and agencies don't want
that to happen" Dr Foskey said.
"We cannot allow the rich and powerful to use the threat of legal action
to shut down legitimate opposition, as Gunns is attempting to do here.
People who are actively involved in the peace movement, in campaigning for
civil rights, or organising against unwanted development, as well as those
fighting to protect our environment, are justifiably alarmed at what is
happening in Australia."
"Strategic Litigation Against Public Participation" [SLAPP] cases are being
pursued around the world, and the Gunns case is the example with the
highest profile in Australia. I have introduced a Bill to the ACT
Legislative Assembly that is designed to protect public participation by
defining the intimidatory use of legal action as improper, and ruling it
out for that reason" Dr Foskey said.
The other speakers will be Leanne Minshull (former Wilderness Society
employee and a Gunns 20 defendant), Paul Collins (broadcaster and former
Catholic Priest) and Bill Lines (environmental historian and author). The
discussion will be moderated by Dr James Prest, solicitor for the ACT
Environmental Defender's Office.
|
|
Tuesday 21st September 2005
NEW LAWS TO PROTECT FREE SPEECH URGENTLY NEEDED
|
New laws to guarantee free speech and public participation are
urgently needed to protect the community from the intimidating effects of lawsuits
that can lead to silencing public debate, campaigners visiting Sydney as part of
national tour today said.
Community advocates meeting at NSW Parliament today, including the Council for
Civil Liberties, the Asbestos Diseases Foundation and defendants in a $6.8 million
dollar civil lawsuit by Gunns Ltd, Australia's largest export woodchip company,
called for legislation to protect free speech and public participation.
"Community campaigns in Sydney and across NSW, such as the ones to prevent a
charcoal plant at Mogo on the south coast and lifting the lid on the terrible impact
of asbestos, would no longer be possible if the legal action Gunns Limited is taking
now is successful," tour co-ordinator and Gunns defendant Louise Morris said.
Standing up for free speech and the rising national awareness of Tasmania's forests
are the focus of the Forest and Free Speech National Tour, which will also involve a
public meeting tomorrow night at the University of Technology Broadway, starting at
6pm.
Ms Morris said that over the past 12 months they have been able to save over 180,000
hectares of Tasmania's old growth forests from woodchipping, such as the Tarkine
rainforest wilderness and parts of the Styx Valley of the Giants.
"The last election has shown that even the most conservative of governments, a
Howard Federal Government and a Lennon State Government, have had to bow to public
opinion and protect parts of Tasmania's forest.
"Gunns Limited is suing 20 defendants, claiming damages for media statements,
disruption to its logging operation and what they claim is unlawful lobbying of
shareholders, customers and governments. This is a landmark case, which may forever
change the face of free speech in Australia.
"This speaking tour is a call to action for all Australians to show their support
for Tasmania's old growth forests and those who have tried to defend them to preserve
these world class forests for future generations, and to gain support for laws which
protect our right to speak out in the future," Ms Morris said.
For more information, please call: Paul Sheridan, 0410 516 656
|
|
Tuesday 6th September 2005
NATIONAL FREE SPEECH TOUR ROLLS INTO NEWCASTLE
|
Tasmanian forests campaigners, including defendants
in the historic Gunns 20 legal action, will visit Newcastle
next Thursday, 15 September, as part of a national tour to
highlight the importance of free speech and the impact the
case could have on community activism.
Free speech in Newcastle and across Australia and the community's
right to protest risks being seriously curtailed if legal
action in relation to Tasmania's old growth forests is successful.
Gunns Limited has taken legal action against 20 campaigners
and its $6.8 million civil lawsuit is currently being considered
in the courts.
The tour is also a celebration of how successful the forest
campaigners have been in raising the awareness of all Australians
about the importance of Tasmania's old growth forests.
The evening of the 15th will also feature short films,
comedy, prizes, dance and musical performances, food and
drinks. The evening will begin at 6.30pm at Honeysuckle
Warehouses Civic (ticket information below).
Spokesperson for the Gunns 20 Fundraising Team, Claire
Dunn explained "This is the first time in Australia
that a large corporation is attempting to sue activists
for engaging in a public campaign. It could set a dangerous
precedent that would inhibit free speech."
Local Gunns 20 defendant Ben Morrow said "Now is an
important time for the community to stand behind those who
have been so successful in protecting our forests through
peaceful protest. This case affects anyone who reserves
the right to lobby against what they see as unjust, a right
so essential to Australian society."
Forests and Free Speech Tour organiser and Gunns 20 defendant
Louise Morris said "A number of the key people and
organisations who helped saved these forests have been served
with a $6.8 million civil law suit by Gunns Ltd, Australia's
largest export woodchip company.
"This speaking tour is a call to action for all Australians
to show their support for Tasmania's old growth forests
and those who have tried to defend them to preserve these
world class forests for future generations, and to gain
support for laws which protect our right to speak out in
the future," Ms Morris concluded.
The case is ongoing and is frequently updated at www.gunns20.org.au.
Tickets can be purchased from The Wilderness Society, 90
Hunter St Newcastle, phone (02) 4929 4395.
|
| Monday 29
August 2005
SPEAKERS CORNER LAUNCH TO HIGHLIGHT FREE SPEECH IN TASMANIAN
FORESTS |
Standing
up for free speech and the rising national awareness of Tasmania’s
forests will be the focus of the Forest and Free Speech National
Tour launch at Speakers Corner, in King George Square, in
Brisbane tomorrow.
Alec Marr, The Wilderness Society’s Campaigns Director,
and Jo Bragg, Principal Solicitor at the Queensland Environmental
Defenders Office will discuss the importance of free speech
and the Tasmanian forests campaign to Brisbane residents.
The tour will highlight the ongoing campaign to protect
Tasmania’s forests and the Australia-wide implications
of woodchip company Gunns Limited’s $6.8 million civil
lawsuit against forest campaigners.
Speakers Corner, Brisbane’s dedicated venue for free
speech, will be decked out with banners highlighting the
importance of Tasmania’s forests and campaigners will
distribute leaflets and discuss the tour with locals from
10am.
A public meeting will also take place on Wednesday, 31
August, at 7pm in the Visy Theatre, Brisbane Powerhouse,
119 Lamington Street, New Farm.
When: Tuesday, 30 August
10am, press conference at 10.15am
Where: Speakers Corner
King George Square |
| Tuesday 23 August 2005
TEST OF FEDERAL LEGISLATION AT WIELANGTA |
Dozens stood outside the Federal Court in Hobart this morning
in support of Senator Bob Brown's courageous stand on behalf
of millions of ordinary Australians.
Convenor of the South East Forest Protection Group, Ms
Helen Gee welcomed the (June) decision of the Federal Court
to put Forestry Tasmania's environmental exemptions on trial
and, together with many supporters, awaits the outcome of
today's Directions Hearing.
"The exemption of the woodchip industry from the Environmental
Protection legislation (EPBC Act 1999) is clearly intolerable",
Ms Gee said. "Setting this double standard, the RFA gave
immunity to one special group in our society. Was it really
intended for loggers to be licensed to drive threatened
wildlife closer towards extinction?
"While it is good news that Forestry Tasmania has agreed
to hold off the logging of one of the contentious coupes
on Wielangta Hill, it is lamentable that logging has commenced
in another. This is critical habitat for the Wielangta Stag
Beetle, a federally listed species.
"Senator Bob Brown has spoken out for a great many outraged
Tasmanians and is congratulated by our Group for achieving
a full hearing of this crucial issue, set down for 17 October.
This will be seen as an historic milestone in the long debate
over forestry in this state. The Federal Government, if
they are given leave to intervene, will have to attest to
breaches of the federal environment legislation in this
state", she said.
"Given the fragmented distribution of the Stag beetle,
and the rare and threatened status of a number of other
species, the precautionary principle should be invoked at
Wielangta. The beetle is in such low numbers that all its
known habitat should be protected", Ms Gee said.
|
| Wednesday
17 August 2005
'GUNNS 20' DEFENDANTS COMMENT ON THIRD STATEMENT OF CLAIM |
Version III of Gunns’ statement of claim against
twenty defendants (the ‘gunns20’) was lodged
on Monday.
In striking out the first and second version of the claim
last month, Justice Bongiorno described the documents as
‘unintelligible, ambiguous, vague and too general,
so as to embarrass the opposite party who does not know
what is alleged against him.” He gave the plaintiffs
a month to lodge an amended statement of claim with pleadings
that make clear the allegations against each defendant.
The 221 page amended statement of claim is strikingly similar
to the earlier versions. The total amount of the claim for
compensation has increased by $500,000 to almost $7 million.
This additional claim for compensation is not supported
by any additional allegations of impropriety by the defendants.
The matter is listed for mention in the Victorian Supreme
Court this morning. His Honor’s decision in relation
to costs to date may be handed down at that time.
Lou Geraghty (defendant #14), Senator Bob Brown (defendant
#10) and Virginia Young, representative for the Wilderness
Society (defendant #6) will be available for comment to
the media outside the Victorian Supreme Court following
today’s Mention.
WHERE: VICTORIAN SUPREME COURT
210 William St, Melbourne
Mention: Court Room 6
Comment: Court steps
WHEN: Following the 9:30am mention
TODAY, 17 AUGUST 2005
|
|